Pros & Cons of Powered, Passive Speakers
A look at the pros and cons of powered and passive loudspeakers in church audio.

Article


August 17, 2011 By Mark Helms

One of the most common questions from church clients is whether they should purchase powered or passive loudspeakers. This is, of course, entirely dependent on the situation.

The long and short of it is that CIs need to think about the application. I love using powered loudspeakers for portable church systems since there are fewer cables to lug around, and I’m strong enough to manhandle them on and off poles.

I’ve seen portable setups become semi-installed setups because the people using the system were not able to move the speakers. I tend to prefer the use of passive loudspeakers for installations, but there are many cases where powered models are much more practical.

Here is a look at the pros and cons of powered and passive loudspeakers in church audio.

Powered Loudspeakers

Pros:
Predictable. The amplifier is matched to the loudspeakers, and the factory has tested it.

Negates the need for an additional equipment rack for amplifiers. All components are in one convenient package. They can be connected directly to a mixer or sound source.

Reduces audio quality loss and level loss over longer cable distances, due to the differences between balanced audio wire and loudspeaker wire.

Often the amplifier is tuned to the loudspeaker, so little to no equalization is necessary.

Setup can be more simple and easier to understand for people unfamiliar with sound systems.

Cons:
Portable powered loudspeakers require more lifting power. Installed powered loudspeakers usually require additional rigging and support in the room.

In installed situations, amplifier service must be done at the loudspeaker location.

Passive Loudspeakers

Pros:
Flexible. Allows for potential upgrades without replacing both the amplifier and loudspeaker.

Gets signal from standard loudspeaker wire rather than needing both XLR and power cable.

Lighter weight. Generally simpler to rig in an installation and easier to lift for portable systems.

Service of the amplifier and loudspeaker is more straightforward. The amplifier is easily accessible, and either component can be exchanged for a temporary one.

Cons:
More gear to keep up with, and the amplifier(s) must be located relatively close to the loudspeaker.

More potential for signal loss over long distance.

The amplifier needs to be matched to the loudspeaker for proper sound quality and volume.

This article was republished with permission from ProSoundWeb.

Work Smarter: Keep Ahead of the Competition

Keep up with the changing A/V world with Commercial Integrator. Each issue makes it easy to understand and apply the latest A/V trends and techniques — whether you deal with UHDTV, wireless AV, Digital Video/IPTV, networking, HDBaseT or HDMI.
It's not enough to keep up with the competition. You need to stay ahead of them. Subscribe to Commercial Integrator today for the latest techniques and insights you need to drive your business.

About the author

Mark Helms is a systems designer at Church Audio Video, a company that specializes in the design, installation and support of high-quality and affordable custom audio, video, lighting, broadcast and control systems for worship facilities.
View all posts by Mark Helms
Social Bookmark or Share This
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Google Bookmarks
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • Reddit
  • Windows Live
  • LinkedIn
  • Evernote
  • E-mail


  • Latest
  • Blogs
  • Photos
  • Resources
Genesis Acquisition of Edcom Tells Tale of Two Companies

That Edmonton-based Genesis Integration now has most of Ontario covered with London, Ontario-based Edcom Multimedia acquired is only half the story. $40 million Genesis Integration scoops up assets of $6.5 million Edcom Multimedia, demonstrating one firm poised for growth in a market that is spitting out those that are not.

Winter Is Coming: AV/IT Convergence Is Just a Game of Thrones
3 Ways the Industry Can Improve in 2017
4 Ways the Corporate Market Is Evolving
The Future Is Now: 6 Game-Changing Technology Platforms You Can’t Ignore
View more blog posts
Inside 35 High-Tech Distance Learning Colleges

From innovative web conferencing technology to robust online learning platforms, the following North American universities offer distance learners a variety of educational options to help them earn degrees that are just as valuable as on-campus degrees.

Pub Rethinks Video Wall Usage Using Userful
Donald Trump Inauguration Coming to 11 LED Screens Across Capitol
Afraid of Heights? Christie’s Panoramic Projection of Los Angeles Has You Covered
James Madison University Students Get Real-World Media Experience with Hitachi Cameras
View more photo galleries


Recent comments

Great article, Tom!
Sensory is a great company with smart leaders!

Posted by Kevin Groves on 2017 01 18 · commented on
'Inside Sensory Technologies' Secrets to Mid-Market Success'.

This is all relevant here and now the industry is changing and either be in the know or left behind. Transformation…

Posted by Home Theater San Diego on 2017 01 05 · commented on
'9 Predictions That Will Undoubtedly Impact Your Business by 2021'.

Phil, you are making an important position. 

This industry is too much about dazzling customers…

Posted by Tom LeBlanc on 2016 12 27 · commented on
'2017 CI: State of the Industry Report'.

“Our industry is about creating wonder and experiences. We’ve become a strategic asset, but IT was…

Posted by Phil c on 2016 12 25 · commented on
'2017 CI: State of the Industry Report'.