COVID-19 Update

Forget the Hype: 6 Real Reasons to Choose (or Not Choose) Laser Projection

There are quantifiable reasons why laser projection may be right for your next project and equally measurable reasons why it may not. We help you decide when laser projectors are the right fit.

The 3-chip design in Sony’s 3LCD laser projectors is the major reason for that perceived better color accuracy, according to Phipps. He says having three chips in each device creates a “better” and “optically more efficient” solution than single-chip alternatives.

“In other words, they can use less energy to produce more light and it would give you much better color response, much more color accuracy, if you will, because it’s modulating all three colors all the time,” he says.

Apples to Apples vs. Apples to Oranges

There is a consistency element that also comes into play when considering laser phosphor versus lamp-based projection, and it’s even more of a consideration for customers that would be using two projectors side by side or blending projections.

This benefit is something that Sony sort of stumbled upon in developing its laser projector line, Phipps acknowledges. “The laser phosphor uses a phosphor element to produce light. By nature that is very stable. What I mean by that is if I strike an element of phosphor with a certain amount of energy, I would get a certain response, a certain amount of light over a certain spectrum. It’s very predictable and very consistent.”

The flip-side is that lamp-based projection is a lot less predictable. “If I take a lamp and put current to it, it will produce light,” Phipps says. “But depending on the individual lamps and depending actually on the age of the lamp, the brightness and color will change a lot.”

That matters because a lamp-based projection will look one way right out of the box, and look vastly different after 500 hours of use and other factors. “With laser phosphor, Z-Phosphor, we can create a projector that has a certain color response, a certain color fidelity and it will stay that way,” Phipps says.

Webcast: Register for Real-World Reasons to Choose Laser- over Lamp-based Projection

“This is especially nice if you have two projectors in the same room [or if] they’re blended. In a lot of universities you will get lecture halls where they will have a left projector and a right projector because of the size of the hall or in distance learning. And projectors that have slight color shifts are very noticeable when they’re side by side. With lamp-based projectors it’s almost invariable that you are going to have that.”

Ready? Now Wait!

You’re probably accustomed to using a computer with a solid-state drive. But try to remember what it was like “booting up” your older computers, anxious to get to work but instead tapping your fingers on the desk until it finally was ready.

There is a similar benefit to Sony’s laser projectors versus lamp-based projectors. Lamp projectors need time to warm up and also to cool down, which can be challenging for a presenter.

According to Sony, its laser light source projectors take only nine seconds to get to full brightness so a presentation can start; from standby it takes only one second.

Compared to lamp projectors, laser projectors’ difference in operating convenience is night and day.


Laser Isn’t for Everybody

While it’s easy to list the quantifiable benefits of laser projection, the folks at AVI-SPL and Sony aren’t saying that lamp-based projection isn’t a good fit for many customers.

The flip-side of Laney’s argument that customers using projection for 12-hour clips ought to logically chose laser, obviously, is that many use projection less prolifically. “If you use a projector eight hours a week, a 2,000-hour lamp is going to last you about five years, so you kind of lose the cost-of-ownership that comes with laser because you pay more for a laser projector up front,” he says. “It’s that high-usage cost of ownership where it offers the value. If you’re paying less for a unit that you’re using infrequently like that, they almost become disposable by the time the lamps need to be replaced. The technology [will have] changed.”

There is indeed a “price delta” between a 5,000-lumen lamp-based WXGA projector and a 5,000-lumen laser phosphor projector, Phipps says. “If it’s an application where the projector is used two hours a week and it’s going to take five years to get to the end of the lamp life, [laser] may not make sense.”

Phipps adds, there are also circumstances when a customer is tasked with buying a certain number of projectors and working within a limited budget; meanwhile, maintenance costs fall under a different budget. That customer might choose lamp-based without worrying about lamp replacement costs.

“There are some economics considerations there,” Phipps says. “But we’re seeing that for many customers, laser is the obvious choice, today.”

Webcast: Register for Real-World Reasons to Choose Laser- over Lamp-based Projection

CoronaVirus Update